Collar Vs. Harness – Why Your Dog Needs Both

As a dog owner, you’ve likely faced the collar versus harness debate. While each has its advantages, I’ve learned through experience that your dog can benefit from having both. Here’s why incorporating both a harness and a collar into your dog’s routine can lead to safer, more enjoyable outings for both of you.

The Harness: Comfort and Control

Let’s start with a harness. A harness offers several benefits, especially during walks or outdoor activities.

Better Control

A harness gives you more control over your dog, especially if they are a puller or a jumper. It distributes pressure evenly across the chest, which is safer and more comfortable for your dog compared to the strain on their

neck with a collar.

Safety for Specific Breeds

For certain breeds with respiratory issues, like pugs or bulldogs, a harness is a must-have. It avoids pressure on their throat, ensuring that their airway remains unobstructed during walks.

Ideal for Training

During training sessions, a harness can be incredibly helpful. It allows for gentle guidance without causing discomfort or distress, making it an excellent tool for teaching walking etiquette and commands.

The Collar: Identification and Convenience

While a harness is great for control during walks, collars serve important purposes as well.

Essential for Identification

A collar is ideal for holding ID tags, which are crucial if your dog ever gets lost. Even if your dog wears a harness while on walks, a collar with ID tags should be a constant for quick identification.

Easy to Wear

Collars are easy for dogs to wear around the house or in the yard. They’re less bulky than harnesses, making them more comfortable for long-term wear throughout the day.

Training Tool

For well-trained dogs, a collar can be sufficient for walks. It can also be used alongside a harness during training sessions, providing two points of control and training.

Combining Both for Optimal Safety

Using both a harness and a collar offers the best of both worlds. During walks, use a harness for control and comfort, and keep the collar on for identification.

Transitioning Between Environments

When moving from indoors to outdoors or vice versa, having both a collar and a harness makes the transition smoother. Inside the house, a collar suffices, while a harness can be added for outdoor adventures.

Emergency Situations

In emergencies, having both a harness and a collar can be beneficial. If one fails, the other serves as a backup, ensuring your dog’s safety.


In the debate of collar vs. harness, the answer for most dog owners should be both. A harness provides control and safety during walks, while a collar ensures your dog is always wearing identification. By using both, you cater to the varying needs of your dog in different environments and situations.

Do you use both a collar and a harness for your dog? What are your experiences with each? Share your thoughts and tips in the comments below. Let’s discuss the best ways to keep our furry friends safe and comfortable!



Eleanore is a lifestyle knowledge sharer. She loves to learn about new things and then share that information with others in an effort to help them improve their lives. She's a firm believer that if we all work together, we can make the world a better place.

Press ESC to close